The internet has enabled users to become not only consumers of content but also active content producers. While this transformation has facilitated the freer expression of emotions and opinions, anonymity has also contributed to the increased visibility of sensitive forms of content such as othering and hate speech. Against this background, the primary aim of this study is to examine the content produced under the title ‘kilolu kadın iticiliği’ (‘the unattractiveness of overweight women’) on Ekşi Sözlük and to reveal the structure of digital discourse on the platform. To this end, content analysis, a qualitative research method, was employed; a total of 1,096 entries posted under the relevant title were systematically reviewed, coded using MAXQDA, and analyzed thematically. The analysis yielded three main findings. First, fatphobia is legitimized not only through explicit forms of insult and derogation but also through discourses grounded in health concerns and notions of the ‘normal’ body. Second, the discourse of conditional acceptance, which implies that individuals may become socially acceptable if they meet certain conditions, such as losing weight or exercising, functions as a more implicit form of stigmatization. Third, many of the entries consisted of opposing or counter-discourses, indicating that digital environments should not be regarded solely as spaces in which hate speech is produced, but also as arenas in which stigmatizing discourses are challenged, negotiated, and contested.